Thursday, October 25, 2007

“A Day With the Buffalo and the Elders-Paths to the Future”


All Photos and storyline by Shelley Bluejay Pierce
October 25, 2007


On November 29, 2006, eight little buffalo calves forced their way out of a government enclosure where they, and many other wild buffalo, were being detained in holding pens and experimented on by scientists attempting to produce a "brucellosis-free buffalo herd" in the Yellowstone area.


Only a couple weeks after the escape of these determined young buffalo, the winter hunting season began and the buffalo of Yellowstone were beset with hunters chasing them from place to place trying to fill the state issued hunting tags.

During a very stressful time for the buffalo herd in the harsh winter and deep snows where forage is hard to come by, the buffalo run to escape the hunters and the wildlife "management" officials who haze them with helicopters and snowmobiles. The buffalo would not have chosen an insane place to dwell during the long winter season like the heart of Yellowstone Park. They would have followed their instincts and gone to lower prairie grounds where the food supplies were plentiful.Yet, to this very day, they are forced to abide within imaginary fences and made to comply with an illogical and man made system that each year leads many buffalo to their deaths.


This is the way of life for our sacred buffalo. In beginning this story though, let us all back up and take time to learn about them and why they are sacred to the Native people. As is our tradition, listening to the oral history from a trusted Elder is how we learn our history and deepen our respect for our culture and the legacy of those who have come before. I am honored to share this story as told by Scott Frazier, Santee/Crow, as told to him by his Grandfather.

"This is a segment of a large story that happens just after the flood dried up and is probably as old as the new testament of the Christian Bible. My Santee Grandfather told me the story but it is only a part of a much bigger piece that takes many years to tell.

The idea of the buffalo is older than all present day religions. Through out the world many people adhere to a religion of man to man. This is a religion of buffalo to man to buffalo. It is a religion of giving ones self for the betterment of the people who take care of the buffalo.
In the beginning of our relationship to the sacred life of the buffalo, the people lived inside the earth. It was a time when all things holy were on a sacred path and man was not the leader of the journey; the Creator and First Maker were in charge. In this time as told to me by elders long ago, man was a servant to the sacred and we lived inside the earth because the surface was flooded. Man fed the holy buffalo a food that only man could gather with his hands and it was like clouds.


The first one to come out of the earth and journey to the surface is called First One because he wanted to be more than a servant; he wanted to be holy. Today many related to First One still wish to be holy and struggle with sacred challenges of the ego, control, and power which were set from this time.

First One went to the surface and saw the beauty that was staged there for him to see. There were those living on the surface that would test the holy ones journey to become sacred. The ones that were on the surface would have fun and games with the human because they enjoyed watching things fail and struggle. When First One went to the surface they knew he was coming and put the best things for him to view. He saw no hardships or struggles. They made sure a trap for others would work. The stage was set.

Once First One saw the surface he knew automatically that he would get others to exodus to the surface for a better life where they would be in control. He believed he was seeing paradise and did not know his destiny would unfold into our today. Once that First One and others went to the surface the trap was sprung.

At this time we part from the First One's story and go to the buffalo. When the buffalo missed their first meal because no one brought them their food, they began to ask where First One and the others were. When they found out the First One and others went to the surface they went to look out to see how they people were doing and saw the people suffering without food and shelter. The buffalo felt sad for the poor human beings and they returned to council the other buffalos about what they should do. They had hard choices to discuss. One choice was to stay in the earth and starve because they needed the human to feed them or secondly, they could go out of the earth with no way to return to their old life.

They decided that they would go outside to the surface of earth because the people would always remember the buffalo as holy. They would feed the people themselves. There would be no starvation. They would provide all that the humans needed because the human would remember the buffalo as holy. So they came out of the earth for the people.


Many people ask me, "So why do we pray for the buffalo?" The story talks about changing ones' life for others, knowing what is a holy challenge, and finding truth in your purpose.
We pray for the buffalo because they are holy. They hold the universe together."

(Scott Frazier, Ehnamani, Santee/Crow)




(Prayers for the buffalo. left to right: Robert Pierce, Scott Frazier, Dr. Henrietta Mann)

In September 2007, there were six devoted people who did not forget the buffalo. Though the day was cold and the sky filled with snow, the journey began into the heart of Yellowstone in search of our beloved buffalo. Three men and three women began the day amidst the traffic, stopping at gas stations, passing through forest ranger stations and dealing with the congestion of Yellowstone Park visitors to arrive at the place where one of the buffalo herds was gathered.

The road was lined with tourists who snapped pictures and videos of the buffalo gathered in a large meadow and we made our way through the lines of cars to begin our journey to be with the sacred ones. Marsha Frazier held Dr. Henrietta Mann's arm as they aided each other on the walk up the rocky slope to where the prayers would begin. John Potter carried the drum; my husband, Bear, and I walked behind and felt the day's mood change with each step closer to the buffalo.
(Marsha Frazier, left, walks with Dr. Henrietta Mann up to the place where the prayers will take place.)

Scott led us to a small hill near the herd and we all found our place upon the Earth to sit. As I settled into my place on the rocky slope, I remembered another Grandmother telling me long ago that, "The ground is where all things began and it is where all things will return at the end of their circle. When you sit upon the ground you connect to the very beginning and the very end....like the circle in the web the spider makes." Connection with the Earth and the quiet began to settle around us even though in the distance, traffic noise and tourists went about their way without noticing us at first.

"I don't know how many years it's been that I've joined Mr. and Mrs. Frazier in prayer and ceremony, with and for the Buffalo. It is always an honor. It's what we are built for. Time and space fold in upon themselves in the presence of the Sacred. As we settled ourselves among the sage and bunchgrass, just apart from, yet so much a part of, the herd, we easily became centered in prayer with our elders.

The hand-drum came out and we sang a song that was given to us in a fasting time, at a place not far away in distance but so far away in time. The buffalo listened, swayed, rolled on the earth in time, and joined us in song.

To know that some of this herd may take that song with them to their end fills me with a mixture of hope and sadness. But it was a good day, a blessed day, and perhaps they will, in turn, pass our song on to their young and make it their own.

For now, though, time is endless as we become the song together - the Fraziers and I, Dr. Mann, Bluejay, Bear and Buffalo. May our songs join our heartbeats together in time and become the song of life - renewed, restored - to oneness. Migwetch, ni bo wah"

(John Potter, Lac du Flambeau, Anishinabe inini )

Time never stops and is always moving us forward and through the changes of seasons. Time stands as an unforgiving taskmaster that regulates the passage through eternal tides. One breath at a time and one second at a time adds together to a life well lived or one filled with sadness at missed opportunities to make the world a better place. On this September day there was peace, prayers, songs and the drum joining together with the buffalo and humans in a meadow where time seemed to stand still. The winds calmed, there was no falling snow or rain, the birds called to each other, buffalo slept peacefully or dusted themselves in the soft dirt and simply lived at peace as a family unit.

As Scott began his prayers with the pipe and in praying with and for the buffalo, a door opened that linked our past, present and our future. As Dr. Mann began her prayers in her language and sang her song for the buffalo and for the People, I felt a profound joy at having that precious voice lifting all these things for the buffalo. When John began to play the drum and the song was lifted, again my heart was filled to overflowing. There was so much to be grateful for and so many good prayers being lifted between this family gathered with the buffalo. Time seemed to join what our ancestors had done to the present moment where we were gathered and be carrying forward that hope for the next generations to come to also carry our ways forward into time.


To understand more about what the buffalo mean to our People and in particular, for the Cheyenne, I share this story from Dr. Henrietta Mann in hopes that by knowing our past, we can move these traditions forward to our collective future in a good way.

"The So'taa'eo'o, a group of Cheyennes, are the buffalo people who brought us our sacred buffalo cap and its accompanying ceremony, the Sun Dance or "New Life Lodge." Members of our spiritual community are "the buffalo people." As a buffalo person I am related to the most holy four legged buffalo people who have sustained us over time. Historically, they suffered the same fate the natural, ordinary people of this land did and they, too, were driven nearly to extinction.

Today is no different for the buffalo people and it saddens me deeply that some of them will not live to see another springtime. I was pleased to have joined a pilgrimage and to see them in all their ethereal beauty. What could I do? I could only add my thoughts, my voice, my prayer, and my song to the others and speak to them of my great love and respect for them. I shed tears over the fact that they continue to bless us with their lives. I am blessed.

The buffalo stand as a symbol of endurance and compassion and they continue to represent both physical and spiritual food for the people. They provide that unbreakable lifeline with the sacred past, a lifeline that continues to exist today and stretches far into tomorrow. It is a heart line connection that brings happiness and goodness to all their relations. I greeted them in joy, just as I know my great-grandmother White Buffalo Woman did more than a century ago. The buffalo people taught her, just as she has taught and touched the generations since. For this I thank her. For this I thank the buffalo.

I send my prayers out to the Above Spirit, to the Earth, and to the four sacred directions of the universe for their continued protection and safety. Hahoo! "
( Dr. Henrietta Mann, Cheyenne )

As we completed our prayers, we all sat there with the buffalo herd in silence. The buffalo had been making their low, gentle calls back and forth to each other during the entire time we had been praying and singing for and with them. Yet at the end of the prayers, we all, as one family, sat in peace and silence together. Slowly the real world began to slip back into the moment and the sounds of bustling tourists and cars crept back into the present. And then, as is most often the case with our Native relatives, the laughter began. Gentle teasing and loving laughter went back and forth between us all and we slowly began our journey back to the parking area.

(The laughing and sharing begins! Clockwise- John Potter, Scott Frazier, Dr. Mann, Robert Pierce)

Many tourists asked questions of us upon our return, some took pictures and others seemed connected to the moment as they stared in silence at the buffalo and then towards all of us. We can only pray that some of these visitors were blessed with a new care and respect for the buffalo and will carry that back with them to wherever their everyday lives are lived.

"I was blessed to participate in the prayers for the buffalo in Yellowstone Park and to share that day with such wonderful prayer people like Henrietta Mann. I have shared days like that one with my husband, Scott Frazier and his brother John Potter for probably 20 years. We have made the journey to commune with our Buffalo family before their hard challenge of the winter, year after year. We have been joined by many individuals that heard the call to pray and to assist.

Some have been Native and some have not. For me, not being able to be an enrolled Native American, I have answered to the calls of my Native ancestors, Indian and non-Indian. I have prayed for the well being of my relatives the Buffalo and for them to tell us what they want us to know for the People. In my heart they have shown me what we as the People are and do to one another. They have let me look through the mirror of our existence as the People. They have taught me about how we treat one another and how we should treat one another.

I call out to all of the People, no matter what their lineages are. I call out for prayers, compassion and action. The Buffalo have been forced to evolve into different families with varied lineages because of the choices of others or because of the love of the Creator. They are teaching us about choices and new beginnings. Let us all come together without competition or distraction in our prayers for the Buffalo for they are showing us who we are. Aho!" ( Marsha Frazier, Cherokee )

Many days passed before the joy of that day settled deeply into my heart and I could move forward to thinking on the realities of the present situation of the buffalo on our People. The senseless slaughter of 60 million buffalo brought the herds to the point of extinction. There was no reverence held for the sacred, life-giving buffalo. These creatures were nothing more than money in pockets and an insane "sport" to people who shot them for no purpose other than target practice. There was no honor and no thanks given for the taken life and the buffalo were left to rot beneath the sun.

Likewise, the Native people across Turtle Island were treated similarly and millions of them were simply exterminated. There was no honor and there was no value placed upon the human beings. The remaining Native people were forced out of the way of "progress" and forced onto isolated reservations to live within a confined area. This totally unnatural way of living and the treatment by those who did not or could not understand us reminded me of our treatment of the buffalo.

Scott Frazier once told me that in 1906 there were only 20 wild buffalo living in what is now called Yellowstone Park. At this time, several little orphaned buffalo calves were fed on milk by dairy cows that were brought in from commercial ranches. The dairy cows carried the brucellosis virus and "gifted" it to the buffalo calves in Yellowstone. This little known fact seems eerily similar to the small pox infected blankets being sent into the Piquot nation and others of our People.

The Native people had their children stolen from their arms and their young ones were forced off to boarding schools. Here, the young ones had their hair cut, were forced to wear different clothing, eat different food, speak a foreign language, adopt new stories as their own, walk and live within the confines of square houses and were forced into a new religion. These things were forced upon the People because the outsiders believed they "knew better and what was RIGHT versus what was WRONG." Their decisions were based entirely upon their own interpretations of how all things should be connected and what the balance in the world should be without care that the balance within the Native people had remained healthy for hundreds of years prior to their arrival to Turtle Island.

In similar fashion, "wildlife management experts," in conjunction with political leadership and pressure from the landowners and cattle industry near Yellowstone, have tried to "control" the wild buffalo herd. Many buffalo calves have been stolen away from their mothers at a point in time where they are yet to learn the ways of survival for their first winter season. These young buffalo calves are removed from their relations who speak their language and stripped of the teachings that they learn from their Elders within the herd. They have ear tags punched into their ears to mark them with foreign names. The young buffalo that feasted on the wild prairie grasses are forced to eat commercial hay that is dumped into their square homes. They are tested and prodded, experimented on by scientific research officials, and gradually forget their history and they no longer know they are wild buffalo.

Our people were herded into square houses in confined areas with imaginary fences, were forced to eat strange foods, forbidden to honor our ceremonies and culture and learn a new way that others decided was "right." Our Native people have had their languages banned from use, their food supplies altered, and their stories and ceremonies outlawed The buffalo, just as the Native people, have had their entire natural way of being altered by outside forces.

"It is easy feel connected in a good way when you are in the middle of ceremony and prayer with the buffalo right near you. The challenge comes when you walk away and go back to the lives you lead away from them. Each day we must remember to keep them close and in our prayers. We must hold on to what our ancestors taught us and do our best to walk a good path. We must never forget that the buffalo are our relations and they are sacred."
( Robert "Bear" Pierce, Pikuni Blackfoot )

I have had the honor of walking beside and learning from Scott Frazier over the past few years. There have been times that I thought I understood all that the buffalo mean to us. Each time I arrive at that point, I learn new aspects to this relationship that reaffirms that I still have so very much to learn. What has happened to the buffalo and continues to be the state of being for the herd is reflected back onto the People. When we learn to treat the sacred buffalo in the way that they should be, our People too, may see new and better times in their lives. We are connected; the buffalo and the People, and we must never forget to care for one another.

"The way we as a human race might aid our future generations best, is to teach them to honor the sacred. We must look at the horrors we have created and then seek Creators' direction before moving forward. Look to the buffalo and see what our future holds. Our human treatment of our fellows, the wild ones and our care given to Earth, will determine our future. There is no part of creation more important than another. The big bear is as important as the tiny spider that makes her web. The buffalo are watching. Are you hearing the message?"
(Shelley Bluejay Pierce, Lakota/Cree )


Monday, October 15, 2007

"Majestic Yellowstone Bison Receive Native American Prayers"

Native Americans consider the buffalo sacred for the life giving relationship between the People and the herd. Elders lifted prayers on behalf of the buffalo herd in Yellowstone prior to the winter months when buffalo are hazed or killed for crossing imaginary park boundary lines. From left to right: Dr. Henrietta Mann (Cheyenne) Scott Frazier (Santee/Crow) and John Potter (Ojibway)
[Photo by Shelley Bluejay Pierce]



Storyline and all photos By Shelley Bluejay Pierce

Oct. 15, 2007

(as appeared in various publications, including Cheyenne-Arapahoe Times)


GARDINER, Montana- Sacred prayers and songs were lifted for the Yellowstone buffalo herd by Native American elders led by Scott Frazier (Santee/Crow, and assisted by Dr. Henrietta Mann (Cheyenne) and John Potter (Ojibway). The resting buffalo were gathered in a large meadow on the South edge of Yellowstone Park near the boundary line that stands literally for life or death if crossed by the bison during the winter months when they travel outside park perimeters in search of better forage.

Buffalo herds once numbered 30 to 60 million across North America but were slaughtered nearly to the point of extinction during the late 1800s. As of the spring of 2006, the Yellowstone herd has approximately 3,500 remaining buffalo. Forced to remain inside the confines of Yellowstone Park, the buffalo are subjected to repeated harassment or death as a result of leaving the border lines the animals do not see nor sense.

Buffalo were the sustaining force for the American Indian people for centuries. The balance of supply and demand, weather patterns, and over use of one part of the ecological web affected both bison and human. The plains tribes honor the buffalo in their religious belief and ceremony, depended upon them for their shelter, food, and daily living requirements. Many of the tribes are now part of a hunting program developed by Montana leaders who say buffalo must be killed to keep population in balance. Their efforts are attempting to return some of the buffalo back to the tribes that originally hunted them originally in this area.

Scott Frazier has spent the better part of his life attempting to help protect the Yellowstone herd. When trying to explain the spiritual impact the buffalo have for the people, he explains, "I've been asked many times why the buffalo are so important. I have always seen them as the life that is holy. The buffalo has always been the life force of this land. They gave themselves in many ways so that others could learn, live, and be religiously fulfilled. Peoples of the plains could have not found the strength to exist without the buffalo. There is a power unknown to humans that the buffalo answers."

Scott Frazier lifts prayers on behalf of the buffalo herd with hopes of protecting them through the long, harsh winter months in Yellowstone Park
[photo by Shelley Bluejay Pierce]



Though the struggle to procure extra grazing land as a buffer zone for the bison herd outside the park's boundaries has been attempted, there has not been an entirely affective solution to the problems of migrating buffalo yet.

Despite enormous public outcry by Native tribes, wildlife protection groups and the worldwide community of visitors who come to Yellowstone, the agreement between federal and state agencies continues to places the economic interest of Montana's livestock industry above the welfare of the buffalo herd.

With the Federal and State government agencies in control, the buffalo have been chased by helicopter and snowmobiles, captured and held in pens, endured experimental testing and slaughter programs that have all resulted in the deaths of more than 3,000 Yellowstone buffalo since the mid 1980s. There were 0 kills in the 1999/2000 season but that number skyrocketed to 1,016 buffalo killed during the 2005/2006 season.

Buffalo were gathered in a larger group near the meadow where the prayers were lifted.
[photo by Shelley Bluejay Pierce]

Buffalo are migratory like other wildlife in the park and they naturally seek out better food supplies during the heavy snows in winter and spring. Crossing a park boundary line into the path of domestic cattle is leading to their demise where Montana's livestock industry and the state of Montana maintains a zero-tolerance policy for wild buffalo.

Scott Frazier and those who know the significance of the buffalo hope and pray there will be changes to the treatment the herd has historically been given.

Scott explains this relationship with the buffalo by saying, "The buffalo are trying to awaken us to understand the potential of all relationships to the creation. There are those who walk with the buffalo. They come here to stand in the light of the moment. There is a great relationship happening here, between the holy and the human. It has always been my belief that the buffalo are studying us and relating their findings to the Creator. We are under the microscope of the cosmos in a time when we as humans consider ourselves a higher life form. However, in this time we grow old and change is slow. Many humans do not understand their relationship within the balance and continue to treat the animals poorly. Some humans forget their potential to change and become holy. The buffalo are here to help awaken those people to change. They don't realize that the buffalo are watching."

Monday, August 20, 2007

Crisis of Indian Health Care the Focus of Public Hearing in Montana

By- Shelley Bluejay Pierce

8/20/2007

CROW AGENCY, Montana- Senator Byron Dorgan (D-North Dakota) who chairs the Senate Indian Affairs Committee, journeyed to the Crow reservation in Montana on Wednesday for a hearing which focused on the crisis of health care in Indian country.

An elite panel of experts joined lawmakers in the public meeting that offered the tribal communities a chance to voice their grievances prior to a renewed effort to reauthorize the Indian Health Improvement Act that has not been renewed since 1999.

The hearing prepares the way for the Senate Finance Committee, which is addressing the act.

The Indian Affairs Committee, which has primaryjurisdiction over the bill, has given approval to it. Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-MT), whose committee has partial jurisdiction over portions of the bill, stated that he would schedule a committee session to act on the bill September 12, 2007.

Indian Health Service, (IHS) is a program that provides health care tothe tribes. In Treaties with the United States, provisions for health services to the Tribes became a federal trust responsibility. Despite these agreements made more than a century ago, current health care conditions on the reservations are described as being at "third world levels."

Senator Dorgan has stated in earlier press that he "would not allow another Congress to come and go without acting to improve it. The Indian Affairs Committee approved similar legislation in the previous Congress, but the full Senate never considered it."

According to IHS estimates, Indian patients receive $2,158 per person a year in health care services compared to the average of $5,921 for the general population in the United States.
Senator Dorgan stated in testimony to Congress earlier this year, that even federal prisoners have more spent on them each year, at $3,900 per person.

For more than a decade, the reauthorization of the Indian Health Care Improvement Act has lain at lawmaker's feet but Congress has taken no action. The act expired in 2000 and attempts to reauthorize it have been met with opposition by many Republican members of Congress.

Panel member, Dr. Charles North, Chief Medical Officer (Acting), for Indian Health Service told the attendees that while the mortality rates for Native Americans have improved in recent decades, death and disease rates still exceed that of the general population. Rates of diabetes are 200 percent higher, alcoholism rates are 550 percent higher and suicide rates 57 percent higher than those found in non-Native populations.

Witnesses testified at the hearing of their account of poor health caregiven which included examples of cancer victims received diagnosis long after they might have survived had they received earlier treatment; year long or longer waiting lists for needed surgeries; and trauma victims turned back from tribal clinics not equipped to handle critical cases.

Crow Tribal Chairman Carl Venne voiced his thoughts during the hearing and encouraged IHS employees and tribal leaders to call for more funding. He revealed to the attendees that the Pryor Mountain wild horses receive more annual funding than the Crow-Northern Cheyenne Hospital.

Testimonies at the hearing included information regarding the 1.9 million patients dependent upon the federal Indian Health Service, onec omment was heard frequently. "Don't get sick after June 1."

This comment is referring to the fact that once the yearly funding is depleted, usually during the last quarter of the fiscal year, there is no available funding for health needs in the Native communities. Other testimonies included patients needing specialized care for arthritis, heart conditions, complications from diabetes and other more involved health issues remain on long waiting lists and are left untreated unless they are in danger of losing life or limb.

Basic care is available at local reservation clinics and extreme trauma patients often receive immediate attention as they are referred to emergency rooms or evacuated to larger hospitals.
However, those patients who need specialists necessary for their health care but are not considered life threatening go without treatment.

Jonathan Windy Boy, enrolled member of the Chippewa Cree Tribe, a state Representative in the Montana Legislature, and serving as Chairman on the Committee on Health Care for Montana/ Wyoming Tribal Leaders Council recounted the disparity in care for the more remote reservations.

Since his home reservation is in a remote area, he explained that members with health needs were made to travel hundreds of miles per week to receive treatment in larger cities equipped to deal with their health issues. In his testimony he restated the critical need for Congress to fund the health care at 100 percent and not at 40 to 60 percent that theyhave in the past. According to reports, funding levels in remote communities fair even worse when it comes to the needed levels offunding.

Rep. Windy Boy told the hearing attendees, "The medical inflationary rate over the past ten years has averaged 11 percent. The average increase for the Indian Health Service (IHS) health services accounts over this same period has been only 4 percent. This means that IHS/Tribal/Urban Indian (I/T/U) health programs are forced to absorb the mandatory costs of inflation, population growth, and pay cost increases by cutting health care services."

Windy Boy further detailed the disparity in funding by explaining, "In Fiscal Year 1984, the IHS health services account received $777 million. In FY 1993, the budget totaled $1.5 billion. Still, thirteen years later, in FY 2006 the budget for health services was $2.7 billion, when, to keep pace with inflation and population growth, this figure should be more than $7.2 billion. This short fall has compounded year after year resulting in a chronically under-funded health system that cannot meet the needs of its people."

Another of the panel speakers, Stacy Bohlen, Executive Director of the National Indian Health Board, spoke of the critical need for orthopedic surgeons to address the critical needs of patients requiring such things as hip replacement surgeries. She stated that a patient from the general population in the U.S. will wait two to three months for an orthopedic procedure while Indians in Montana are waiting six years. During this time the patients are using large doses of narcotic painkillers that in the end may lead to substance abuse problems.

Bohlen further explained that many of the joint treatments, if performed earlier,would not need the drastic repairs required when the conditions areleft without proper and immediate care.

Senator Jon Tester (D-Montana) held a telephone press conference immediately before the public hearing began at Crow Agency. His opening remarks highlighted that Senator Dorgan was coming in from Washington D.C. to chair the hearing and highlighted the need to address critically important health care issues in Indian country.

"Improving health care on reservations is critically important to improving all conditions in Indian country. It seems that every time Indian leaders submit a budget for what they truly need to provide basic services, the government says there is just not enough money. This issue is not about money, it's about priorities. If we can spend $3 billion each week in Iraq, then we can surely develop health care systems that live up to our trust responsibilities in Indian country,"stated Senator Tester.

"All the information we say and hear today will become part of theofficial record of the Indian Affairs Committee. This information won't just be stored away in a library in some basement. Sen. Dorgan and I will be taking this information back with us to the Indian Affairs Committee and we will continue to work to change policy toimprove Indian health care," concluded Senator Tester.

Thursday, August 16, 2007

Rep. Diane Watson of California to Discuss Freedmen Issues With Public Meetings in Oklahoma

By Shelley Bluejay Pierce



8/16/2007



MUSKOGEE, Oklahoma- Rep. Diane Watson, the Freedmen Band of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma, and the Oklahoma Legislative Black Caucus will hold public meetings in Tulsa and Muskogee, Oklahoma on Monday Aug. 20, 2007. The Town Hall meetings are being held to hear public debate on the Cherokee Nation's expulsion of the Freedmen.



The panel, which consists of US Rep. Diane Watson and members of the Oklahoma Legislative Black Caucus, and other guests will listen to statements and then respond to questions from the public.



In an August 14, 2007 press release, Rep. Diane Watson stated, "We invite the public to air their views, thoughts, perspectives and questions on this important issue of law. This issue affects not just Cherokees or Freedmen, but all people who recognize that our great nation is nothing without the rule of law."



In March 2007, the Cherokee Nation voted to remove Freedmen and all others who did not have documented Cherokee bloodline lineage from the nation. In May, the Cherokee court readmitted the Freedmen, but on a provisional basis. Freedmen then approached members of the Congressional Black Caucus requesting their assistance in restoring their citizenship in the Cherokee Nation. Rep. Watson introduced legislation (H.R. 2824) that calls for a severing of U.S. relations with the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma.



Included within the bill are recommendations that cut federal funding to the tribe until such time that the Cherokee Nation restores full tribal citizenship to a group of African Americans known as Freedmen. The bill currently has 21 cosponsors and has been endorsed by the NAACP and the National Congress of Black Women according to Rep Watson's official website.



Also from Rep. Watson's website, she states that, "The Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma's push to disenfranchise Cherokee Freedmen represents a fundamental injustice that must not go unchecked. Nothing less than an affirmative and decisive Congressional response will suffice."H.R 2824 has drawn strong reaction from the general public, tribal leaders, and members of various Native nations as well as governmental leaders. Critics of the bill state that this piece of legislation undermines the tribal sovereignty of each Indian nation in the USA. Proponents state that the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma has unfairly excluded members of Freedmen and others who qualify as citizens of the Cherokee Nation based on the 1866 Treaty made with the USA.Both meetings to be held on August 20, 2007 are free and open to the general public.

Location and Time of the Meetings-

Tulsa 12:00 – 2:30 pm
Rudisill Regional Library
1520 North Hartford
918-596-7280

Muskogee 5:30 pm – 8:00 pm
Muskogee Civic Center
425 Boston St
(918) 682-9131

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Rep. Diane Watson of California Attacks the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma With Introduction of H.R. 2824 Legislation

By Shelley Bluejay Pierce

8/12/2007


WASHINGTON D.C.- Questions about tribal sovereignty and who can be a registered citizen of an Indian tribe in the USA became the focus for the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma this past month. California Congresswoman, Diane E. Watson, introduced legislation that calls for a severing of U.S. relations with the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma. ( full text of H.R. 2824 located at http://www.govtrack.us/congress/billtext.xpd?bill=h110-2824 ) Included within the bill are recommendations that cut all federal funding to the tribe until such time that the Cherokee Nation restores full tribal citizenship to a group of African Americans known as Freedmen.

Congresswoman Watson's H.R.2824 essentially punishes the Cherokee Nation for requiring its citizens to have Indian ancestry. Approximately 500 other Indian tribes across the USA mandate that citizens be of verifiable Indian bloodline in order to be a citizen of that tribe. The Cherokee Nation is the second largest tribe in the United States, with about 280,000 members including more than 1,500 citizens who are descendants of Freedmen who have proven Indian ancestry.

Freedmen approached members of the Congressional Black Caucus requesting their assistance in restoring their citizenship in the Cherokee Nation. Rep. Diane Watson, joined by 11 other lawmakers, introduced the bill that threatens to cut millions of dollars in federal funding to the Cherokees.

"A member of congress didn't like a decision that a tribe made and then decided that the tribes' actions warranted congressional intervention and basically tried to serve a death sentence to the tribe. Congress is taking a step toward telling the tribes how to run their nations and going so far as to tell a tribe who is "Indian" and who is not," stated Mike Miller, Communications Officer for the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma.

The Cherokee Nation voted on March 3, 2007 to amend their Constitution to clarify eligibility for Cherokee citizenship. 77% of the voting citizens approved this amendment with more than 8,700 citizens voting which the Cherokee website states, "was a higher turnout than the vote for the Cherokee Nation's constitution, four years ago." The vote followed a petition drive for a ballot measure to determine who is a citizen of the Cherokee Nation. (http://www.cherokee.org/home.aspx?section=services&service=CitizenStatusChanges&ID=beL7Iwv6q28= )

Cherokee Nation spokesman, Mike Miller, further explained, "We have more than 1500 Cherokee citizens who are Cherokee by blood but who also have Freedmen ancestors. We have thousands of other Cherokee citizens who are also African American. The point is if you have an Indian ancestor on our Dawes rolls, then you can be a Cherokee citizen. If you do not have the bloodline connection then you are not a citizen of the Cherokee Nation. This is a question of being INDIAN without discussing any other race involvement. Every other Indian tribe bases their membership this way so why are the Cherokee being treated differently?"

H.R 2824 has drawn strong reaction from the general public. In what seems a backward process, the Cherokee Nation has been given possible penalties by lawmakers prior to official investigations or discussions with proper agencies that deal with tribal affairs. H.R. 2824 details what the lawmakers are requesting in a final phase of judgment, even going so far as to suggest enormous penalties for non-compliance, before formal discussions or investigations have taken place between the leaderships.

The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) voiced strong opposition to the bill in a press statement released on June 26, 2007. In the statement, Joe Garcia, the President of NCAI stated, "It is outrageous to propose to terminate the existence of an Indian Nation. This is an uncalled for response to a legal question of treaty interpretation. When Alabama or California takes an action inconsistent with Congressional views, there is no discussion of revoking their statehood. The attempt to revoke tribal nationhood is equally inappropriate. Not since the Termination Era of the 1950's, when the official policy of the federal government was complete destruction of indigenous peoples, have we seen such a piece of legislation. NCAI was founded to oppose termination of Indian tribes."

Additionally, the bill addresses actions directed at other tribes who have Freedmen connections stating, "Not later than 6 months after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Secretary shall issue a public report to Congress on the status of freedmen in the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chickasaw, Muscogee (Creek), and Seminole Nations of Oklahoma."

Chief Chad Smith has stated in previous press coverage, "My roll as Principal Chief was to bring the issue of citizenship to a vote. Determination of citizenship is the decision of the people, not the Principal Chief, not the tribal council and not the court."

H.R 2824 suggests punishing tribes for decisions made within their own nations if this bill is approved in its current form. Tribal sovereignty refers to the inherent authority of indigenous tribes to govern themselves. Native tribes have fought a long battle to secure tribal sovereignty in regards to fair and equitable relationships between Washington leadership and the tribes.

A 1981 legal case, Montana v U.S., clarified that, 'tribal nations possess inherent power over their internal affairs, and civil authority over non-members within tribal lands to the extent necessary to protect health, welfare, economic interests or political integrity of the tribal nation.' Elected tribal governments have the legal ability to determine actions that impact their citizens as well as setting their own criteria for membership. The Indian Education and Self-Determination Act in the mid-1970s sought to re-establish sovereignty amongst the Indian nations. H.R. 2824, in its current form, is suggested to undermine all the progress that has been made in regards to the tribes maintaining self-determination.

"To say that the Freedmen have always been members of the Cherokee Nation regardless of blood quantum is not accurate. From 1975 to 2006, each citizen of the Cherokee Nation had to have provided a blood relation link to an Indian citizen on the rolls. Blood line had to be established or you were not accepted into the Cherokee Nation," stated Mike Miller.

The Cherokee official website explains that Freedmen and other non-Indians were granted tribal citizenship under a tribal court ruling just one year ago. Prior to that and following this vote, to be part of the Cherokee Nation at least one Indian ancestor listed on the base roll was required for Cherokee citizenship status to be granted.

Some vocal critics of the Cherokee Amendment suggest that they have been denied membership based on greed. In earlier mainstream press reports, references to the large sums of money earned by various casinos are targeted as a possible reason for the Cherokee Nation limiting its membership. In discussing this with Native American Times, spokesman, Mike Miller, explained the many inaccuracies in this suggestion.

Cherokee casino earnings are invested back into the nation and are not paid out to individual citizens. (http://www.cherokee.org/docs/WTMGWeb.pdf) The casino earnings are used to help fund and expand important government services including health care and education. Though many other tribes across the USA pay out a per-capita check that each citizen of the tribe receives from casino earnings, the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma does not follow this method.

The Bureau of Indian Affairs acknowledged in a letter dated August 9, 2007, that the federal government no longer has the authority to approve amendments to the Cherokee Nation Constitution. Carl Artman, BIA's top official, cited a June 23, 2007 vote of the Cherokee people and agreed that federal approval of amendments to the Cherokee Nation Constitution would no longer be necessary.The letter ends an eight-year struggle by the Cherokee Nation to remove the BIA from its Constitutional process.

When U.S. lawmakers return from their Summer break, committee meetings and investigations will continue into the issue of Cherokee citizen requirements and take aim at the very foundations of tribal sovereignty. While the process moves forward to resolution, the business operations of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma are expected to move forward unhindered.

In a letter to Chief Chad Smith, the U.S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Indian Affairs Deputy Director, Jerry Gidner, stated that the Department intended to continue providing Federal funding to the Cherokee Nation, unless otherwise directed by a Federal court or Federal legislation.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Radiation Warning Signs Placed on Cheyenne River

( Photo courtesy of "Defenders of the Black Hills" )



by Shelley Bluejay Pierce

7/29/2007

SOUTH DAKOTA-Radiation warning signs were posted on Wednesday, July 18, 2007 in the small town of Red Shirt, South Dakota which lies on the northwest corner of the Pine Ridge Reservation. Several of these signs were placed warning people of the high nuclear radiation levels found in the Cheyenne River.
Several weeks ago Everitt Poor Thunder, a spiritual and community leader in Red Shirt, asked Defenders of the Black Hills, an environmental organization, whether the Cheyenne River water could be used to irrigate a community garden. A local well could not be used as it was found to be radioactive and warning signs surround that structure. The water well taps into the Inyan Kara aquifer that also contains the Lakota and Fall River formations, making up an extremely large aquifer of water supplies for many regions.
Residents of Red Shirt occupy a village site that is thousands of years old to the Oglala Tetuwan (Sioux) people. Many have lived here all of their lives, growing gardens with water taken from the Cheyenne River and fishing for catfish, bass, and turtles. In the summer months, the river is used for swimming and other recreational pursuits.
A water sample taken from the Cheyenne River was sent to a laboratory and the results revealed levels of alpha radiation above the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Maximum Contaminant Level. Alpha radiation causes harm when ingested hence the warning signs were placed to warn people of the dangers in the Cheyenne River.
The portion of the Cheyenne River Basin that lies in southwestern South Dakota drains about 16,500 square miles within the boundaries of the state. The area in this basin includes part of the Black Hills and Badlands, rangeland, irrigated cropland, and mining areas. After traversing the western half of the state from southwest to northeast, the Cheyenne River flows into Lake Oahe, a reservoir on the Missouri River.
Previous efforts remove the radiation in the water at Red Shirt have been unsuccessful. Drinking water is piped in, or residents must drive 25 miles to the little town of Hermosa to buy water. The Cheyenne River has dried up approximately one mile from Red Shirt and tests of the river bottom soil by Defenders of the Black Hills are pending. Initial tests using a Geiger counter revealed more than double the amount of normal background elevations for radiation.South Dakota news reports recently referred to a DENR report and stated that uranium is naturally occurring in that area which is said to account for the radiation levels in the water.
"If that was the case, there would not have been villages there for thousands of years. There would have been no fish or any aquatic life previously in this river. We sampled the river with nets for aquatic life and found only 2 crayfish and about 10 minnows in more than 100 yards of the river. In essence, it's a dead river. There are two endangered species that use this River: the Sturgeon chubb, a small fish, and the Bald Eagle," explained Charmaine White Face, founder and Coordinator of Defenders of the Black Hills.
According to published information in the The 2006 South Dakota Integrated Report For Surface Water Quality Assessment the Cheyenne River water quality continues to be generally poor. The lower Cheyenne drainage, in general, contains a high percentage of erodible cropland and rangeland in west central South Dakota. Historical mining records for the state show more than 4,000 exploratory uranium mining holes, some large enough for a man to fall into, in the southwestern Black Hills with an additional 3,000 holes just 10 miles west of the town of Belle Fourche, SD. These mining holes go to depths of 600 feet.

At a meeting for the Defenders of the Black Hills on Feb 26th 2005, discussions centered on the radiation levels in some areas reported at a staggering 1,400 times higher than the ordinary background radiation on the Grand River in the Cave Hills and the adverse affects to the villages on the Standing Rock Indian Reservations. Also discussed was the high proportion of cancer related illnesses and birth defects especially in the small community of Rock Creek.
"There are also hundreds of abandoned uranium mines in Wyoming whose runoff comes down the Cheyenne River, and also 29 abandoned mines in the southwestern Black Hills, all upstream of Red Shirt Village. One of the largest open-pit abandoned uranium mines in the southern Black Hills is a square mile and its runoff goes into the Cheyenne River," explained Charmaine White Face.

Most recently, a Canadian mining company, Powertech, began drilling uranium exploratory wells in the Dewey Burdock area northwest of Edgemont. Defenders of the Black Hills battled in court against the drilling permit allowing Powertech to drill 155 more exploratory wells at depths of 500-600 feet in the southwestern Black Hills but the Courts allowed the drilling after denying the appeal. Powertech currently has 4,000 uncapped, and unmarked uranium exploratory wells drilled previously. The mining company plans on doing In Situ Recovery (ISR) of uranium from the Lakota and Fall River aquifers. In Situ Recovery was formerly known as In Situ Leach (ISL) mining.

During the ISR process, a solution to dissolve the uranium is poured down the wells and the dissolved uranium brought back up to the surface. The uranium is separated from the remaining radioactive waste solution that is then reinjected into the aquifer after being held in waste ponds on the surface.

According to Powertech's mining application, each exploratory drill hole "will have a small excavated mud pit that will be approximately 12 feet by 5 feet" and 10 feet deep.
Among the concerns of the environmental groups are the possibility of overflow from the mud pits with the sudden rain showers that occur in the Black Hills. One of the aquifers empties directly into the Cheyenne River and is used by many ranchers to water their livestock. Among the deeper aquifers of concern is the Madison that provides water for many western South Dakota communities.

"A list of uranium mining facts provided online by our organization, Defenders of the Black Hills, reveals a long history of abuses regarding uranium and coal mining in the Upper Midwest region. In an area of the USA that has been called "the Bread Basket of the World," more than forty years of mining have released radioactive polluted dust and water runoff from the hundreds of abandoned open pit uranium mines, processing sites, underground nuclear power stations, and waste dumps. Our grain supplies and our livestock production in this area have used the water and have been exposed to the remainders of this mining. We may be seeing global affects, not just localized affects, to the years of uranium mining" concluded Charmaine White Face.

Monday, June 18, 2007

Tensions build between Seneca Nation and State of New York Over Separate Issues of Land Use and Taxes

By Shelley Bluejay Pierce

Monday, June 18, 2007

ALBANY, NY- A current land usage dispute between the Seneca Nation and the State of New York have increased tensions between the two entities this past week. On Tuesday, the President of the Seneca Nation, Maurice John Sr., submitted a bill to Governor Eliot Spitzer and the New York Transportation Department for more than $2.1 million.

The amount due is based on charging one dollar per vehicle for each of the 28,000 vehicles that travel daily across the three mile stretch of the I-90 Thruway built on tribal lands.

"We're sending the check to New York State, the DOT, it's not up to us whether they pay it or not, it's up to New York State," replied Maurice John during the press conference on Tuesday.

The Seneca Tribal Council voted on May 12, 2007, to charge the state for highway tolls retroactively to April 14, 2007. This decision was rendered after the council voted to rescind a 1954 right-of-way agreement between the nation and the state of New York for the I-90 Thruway that crosses tribal land.

The first Thruway bill sent by the Seneca leadership on Tuesday does not include historic penalties or costs for damages to native lands but if the bill is not paid in full within the 10 day time limit, interest penalties will be applied.

The Seneca Nation said the original land agreement, which paid the tribe $75,000, was invalid from inception due to the documents having never received proper federal approval. Tribal leaders have requested negotiations over the issues with New York State but no discussions have been set to date.

Conflicts between Gov. Spitzer and the Seneca nation have been on the increase since Spitzer assumed office in January. The Governor announced his intentions of collecting state tax on reservation sales of cigarettes and gasoline to non-Indian customers. The Seneca leadership insists that their tribal protection from state taxation is mandated according to the terms of treaty agreements made between the tribe and the United States.

"The Thruway tolls had nothing to do with the tax fight. We're talking apples and oranges," Maurice John stated.

Governor Spitzer's proposed budget for this year includes $200 million in revenues from reservation sales, though the administration has not yet disclosed how those figures will become a reality. The Seneca nation demands that treaty stipulations regarding the tax-free status be honored. The current charges for access to the land the New York Thruway crosses deals with legal contracts and agreements totally separate from any historical treaty agreements.

Tribal leaders displayed architectural drawings during the press conference of a tollbooth they might consider erecting across the roadway in dispute. Erecting signs that clearly alert motorists that they have entered into Seneca territory is one of the immediate actions planned by the tribe.

In 1994, New York won a U.S. Supreme Court Case over the Indian tax collection effort that some officials for the state claimed would increase state income by as much as $400 million a year. Officials attempted to enforce cigarette and gasoline tax laws on Indian retailers back in 1997 but gained only protests, blocked portions of the Thruway and clashes with New York state police.

Seneca leadership has taken aim as well, at a 1976 agreement that allowed construction of the Southern Tier Expressway which in now Interstate 86, and resides upon the Allegany Reservation. Maurice John explained that the tribal council has extended a deadline for negotiations with the state on that issue for one month.

Asked for an official comment from the New York Governor's office regarding their having received the bill from the Seneca Nation, Spitzer spokeswoman Christine Pritchard said, "The governor's office is declining comment."